I wanted to like this book. I really did. After all, I had loved the author, Melina Marchetta's award winning Jellicoe Road, so the thought of an author I admire writing in a genre I love, Fantasy, made me all giddy with Librarian Excitement.
Besides that, the book was getting great reviews and winning awards. Marchetta's web page says that Finnikin of the Rock is "an epic fantasy of feudal intrigue, ancient magic, bloodshed and exile, and two opposing lovers destined to unite . ."
Now, doesn't that sound interesting?
Yes, yes it does.
But when I began to read the book, I found I was rather bored and didn't care much one way or the other WHAT happened to Poor Finnikin. I finally jumped ship about a third of the way in.
I've been thinking about it and here is what I think my problem was.
1. Jellicoe Road is all about the characters placed in a mind bending, time twisting, gem of a mystery plot. I never knew what was going to happen next, and I cared about the characters. I cared a lot. The people seemed so flat in Finnikin of the Rock in comparison. Marchetta just kind of throws them out there and takes it for granted that they are who she says they are because she says so.
2. The fantasy genre depends on the action, and you'd better keep it moving, Bub. Wandering desperately and hopelessly toward a lost homeland, while desperate and hopeless, is hardly exciting. Marchetta DOES have her characters fight, she does, but she does not seem comfortable writing the conflicts, and they did not ring true for me.
3. Marchetta sounds so stuffy in her author blurb in the back of the novel. She is making a Socially Relevant Point, People, and You Had Better Sit Up and Take Notice! She doesn't need to know a thing about Fantasy or "read any of the Greats," thank you very much, because she is going to write about Displaced People, and she is going to use Fantasy to do so.
Read it and see what you think. (MHouse)
Here We Go! Wheeeee
Posted at 04:32 AM in Weird Comments | Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBack (0)
|